GuideCompare

Carboy vs Bundle, BOM and Shared Inventory Apps

Bundle and BOM apps build one item out of others: a gift set uses one of each product inside it. Shared inventory apps such as VSI or Duplicup give several variants one stock number, each sale taking a set number of units. Carboy counts a container in ml or grams: a 5 ml decant takes 5 ml from a 100 ml bottle, then every size is recounted.

Updated November 12, 20267 min readBy Carboy

Search the Shopify App Store for shared inventory and three kinds of app come back: bundle and bill of materials (BOM) apps, inventory sync apps, and apps that give several variants one stock number. All of them keep one number tied to another. They differ in what they count, and that decides whether they fit a shop that pours or weighs its sizes from one container.

Bundle, BOM and sync apps

AppWhat its listing says it is forFree planPaid plans from
Shopify BundlesFixed bundles and multipacks made in the Shopify admin, with inventory updated in real timeFree appFree
Simple Bundles & KitsBundles, kits, multipacks, build your own bundle and BOGO offers, with inventory sync to 3PL and fulfillment3 bundles and 50 orders a month$14 a month under 100 orders, $24 on Shopify Basic
Bundles.app Inventory SyncBundles, multipacks, mix and match sets and tiered pricing, with inventory kept in syncNone, 15-day free trial$19 a month
Material ManagerRaw material and BOM stock linked to variants, with purchase orders and forecasting3 materials, 5 variants per material, 100 orders a month$19.99 a month
Easify Inventory SyncDuplicate SKUs, variants with shared inventory, bundles and raw materials in one store, and sync between storesFirst 150 single-store syncs$9.99 a month
CarboyBottles, bags, sacks and drums counted in ml, g, oz or lb, with every size sold from them recounted3 pools, every feature$12 a month for up to 25 pools

Apps that share stock between variants

AppWhat its listing says it doesWhat one sale takes, per the listingFree planPaid plans from
VSI: Variants Shared InventoryGroups variants of one or several products under one shared inventory, for printed shirts, cups and composite productsA quantity multiplier set per variantNone, 7-day free trial$4.99 a month on Basic Shopify, up to $9.99 on Plus
ONE: Variants Shared InventoryGroups selected variants to share one stock quantity, and marks them sold out when it reaches zeroA stock reduction value set per variantNone, 7-day free trial$2.99 a month
DuplicupKeeps products and variants with the same SKU in sync, for an item listed on several pagesMatching SKUs share one count; paid plans add link groups for bundles and packs3 duplicate SKU groups, 50 syncs a month$13.99 a month
PoolSyncInventory pools synced to every linked variant, with hourly reconciliation and a safety bufferA consumption multiplier: its example is 1 oz = 1 unit, 4 oz = 4 unitsNone, 14-day free trial$14.99 a month
OneShelfOne base stock behind blanks, raw materials, kits and decants, with a checkout rule against carts that ask for more than is leftWhat that listing uses from the base stockUp to 10 base stocks, every feature$9.99 a month
OneCountPools that share one count across variants, multi-packs and bundlesPacks in units: its example is a 10 ml decant taking 10 ml1 pool or bundle$9.99 a month

Descriptions, free plans and prices in both tables were read from each app's own Shopify App Store page on 8 November 2026. VSI (by Addify) and ONE (by Enhance Merchants) are two different apps with similar names. Listings change, so check the page before you choose.

What each kind of app counts

A bundle app counts items. A bundle is a product made of other products. When a gift set sells, the app takes one of each product inside it, and the set shows as many as its scarcest part allows. A 3-pack takes three of the single.

A BOM app counts materials. It links a finished variant to the materials that go into it. Material Manager's listing puts it as linking component inventory to variants once, after which every sale updates raw material and product stock. That is the model for makers: wax, wicks and jars become candles.

A shared inventory app counts one number for several variants. You group the variants, give the group one stock number and set what each one takes when it sells. That is close to how Carboy works, and OneShelf and OneCount name decants on their listings. Duplicup is different: it matches variants by SKU, so it suits one item listed twice rather than sizes poured from one bottle.

Carboy counts a container. A 100 ml bottle is 100 ml and a roast is 4,536 g. Every size sold from it takes its own amount, and each size's stock is worked out from what is left: sellable = (amount left − reserve) ÷ size, rounded down.

What to ask a shared inventory app

  • The unit. Carboy keeps a pool in ml, g, oz or lb and converts between them, so a 4 oz bag and a 100 g bag take from one sack. In an app with a multiplier you choose what one unit is; check that a 2.5 ml size, or a 12 oz bag from a pool kept in grams, can be set up the way you sell it.
  • Refunds and cancellations. Check that the amount goes back when you restock an item, and stays out when you don't. Carboy follows the restock choice you make in Shopify.
  • Hand edits. When someone changes a variant's stock in Shopify, does the app overwrite it, take it into the group or ask? Carboy holds the change and asks whether to add it to the pool.
  • Checkout. The ONE, Duplicup and OneShelf listings name Checkout under Works with, and OneShelf's checkout rule stops a cart that asks for more than is left. Carboy adds nothing to your storefront or checkout (see below).
  • Leaving. Carboy saves Shopify's numbers before it first writes to a size, and Undo linking in its Linking history puts them back.

Decants and portions in a bundle app

Shops do fit decants into bundle apps. The usual way is a hidden item for 1 ml, with 100 units for a 100 ml bottle, and each size set up as a bundle that uses 2, 5 or 10 of it. It holds while every size is a whole number of that unit. A 2.5 ml size needs a 0.5 ml unit, a 12 oz coffee bag is 340.2 g and needs a 0.1 g unit, and every size of every product is one more bundle to build and keep.

Whatever you use, refund and cancel a test order before you rely on it, and check that the amount goes back where you expect.

Which one fits the job

The jobWhat fits
Gift sets, kits and 3-packs of finished productsA bundle app
Boxes that shoppers build themselvesA bundle app with build your own bundle
Raw materials into finished goods, with purchase ordersA BOM app such as Material Manager
The same SKU listed in several storesA sync app such as Easify
One item listed on several product pages under one SKUA same-SKU app such as Duplicup
Printed designs on one blank, each using one of itA shared inventory app such as VSI, ONE or OneShelf
Decants, tea, coffee, spices or refills sold by size from one containerCarboy

What Carboy does for portions

  • Sizes from the variant name. Sample / 2ml, 250g bag, 12 oz and 1 lb are read as sizes; a name without one is typed once. Set up many scans the catalog and creates every pool at once.
  • Units converted inside the pool. A 4 oz and a 100 g size can share one sack.
  • A reserve for spills and testing that is never offered for sale.
  • Refunds and cancellations put the amount back only when you restock them in Shopify.
  • A nightly check at 03:00 store time takes in any order Shopify failed to send and checks every size against its pool.
  • The To fill list, cost and margin per size, and a run-out forecast from the last 28 days of sales, on every plan.

What Carboy does not do

  • No kits. Each variant draws from one pool, so a sampler that takes from five teas is not taken from five pools. Kits and gift sets belong in a bundle app.
  • No purchase orders, no batch or lot tracking and no label printing.
  • One store, one location per pool. It does not sync stock between Shopify stores, and Etsy and other marketplaces are not supported.

Nothing on your storefront

Carboy has no theme app extension and no app embed, so it puts no script on your store pages and nothing in checkout. It reads products and orders and writes only inventory counts: it never changes prices, titles or products. A bundle app works the other way on purpose: the bundle is a product shoppers buy, and some add storefront features too. Simple Bundles' listing names a build your own bundle experience, cart upsells and a sticky cart.

Running another app and Carboy together

They can sit side by side: a bundle or shared inventory app for gift sets and blanks, Carboy for the sizes poured or weighed from a container. Keep each variant under one of them. Carboy only writes the sizes it can explain, and when something else changes a size's stock it holds the change and asks whether to add it to the pool. Two apps setting the same number would keep tripping that check.

For the wider picture, with spreadsheets and counting by hand next to the apps, read Shared inventory across sizes.

Try it on one bottle or one roast. Your first three pools are free, with every feature.